Home > Articles > Hussain v Armstrong Watson LLP: proportionality, disability and template dismissal letters

Hussain v Armstrong Watson LLP: proportionality, disability and template dismissal letters

In Hussain v Armstrong Watson LLP, the Employment Tribunal upheld a claim for discrimination arising from disability under section 15 of the Equality Act 2010 and awarded the claimant £24,826.79.

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Specific advice should be taken on the facts of any individual case.

Background

The claimant had epilepsy, and the Employment Tribunal accepted his evidence that, because of his disability, he experienced focal (or absence) seizures which impacted his memory, concentration and speed of processing. The claimant resigned because a so-called template letter led him to reasonably believe that, despite having raised disability-related reasons and providing a medical report for discussion, the employer was moving toward dismissal without genuinely considering adjustments.

The employer had concerns about the time the claimant was taking to complete tax returns, and the Employment Tribunal accepted that ensuring work was done efficiently and profitably for clients was a “legitimate business aim”.

The case turned not on whether the employer was allowed to have those concerns, but on whether its way of achieving those aims was “proportionate” once the employer became aware of disability-related issues.

Why this judgment matters

This is a useful case for employers because it shows that a legitimate aim does not end the analysis, as in reality, businesses are often able to show they have a legitimate aim for their actions. In section 15 cases, the real battleground is often proportionality. The Employment Tribunal expressly said proportionality involves an objective balancing exercise between the employer’s reasonable needs and the discriminatory effect on the employee. It also noted that treatment will not be proportionate if less discriminatory measures could have been taken to achieve the same objective.

The employer was not wrong to raise performance concerns

The Tribunal did not criticise the employer for monitoring time, raising concerns about utilisation, or asking what support the claimant needed. Up to and including 15 September 2023, the Tribunal found that challenging the amount of time being taken, explaining the need for work to be undertaken profitably and properly recorded, and asking whether there was any explanation or help that could be provided was proportionate. That is an important point. Employers are not prevented from managing performance simply because disability may be involved.

In fact, questioning performance concerns was probably the right thing to do, as it opens a dialogue with the employee to discover why there may be performance issues, and to see if there are any measures the employer could take to support the employee, including making adjustments for disability

Where proportionality started to fail

The problem arose when the process escalated. The Employment Tribunal was not persuaded that it was proportionate to arrange a meeting on 20 September 2023 at which the claimant was told he might be dismissed without a further attempt to explore why he was taking too much time and what might be done to address the issue. Whilst the Employment Tribunal accepted that the employer had genuine performance concerns, it said that by that stage, it should at least have been aware of the possibility that some of the issues were disability related.

That said, the Tribunal did not treat everything after 20 September as automatically unlawful. It is accepted that when the claimant first expressly requested extra time by reference to a medical report, the response that the report would be reviewed and that performance and possible adjustments would be considered in light of it was, on its face, a proportionate response. The employer still had room to recover the situation.

Problems with a “template letter”

The decisive issue was the probationary review letter sent on 26 September 2023. The Employment Tribunal found it was a standard or template letter produced by the People Team and approved by the relevant decision-maker. It warned that dismissal might be the outcome, but it did not refer to the earlier meeting, the medical report, or the intention that possible adjustments would be explored.

That mattered because proportionality is judged objectively.

The employer alleged that it still intended to discuss the report and possible adjustments, but the letter did not say so. The Tribunal accepted that the claimant could reasonably read it as meaning that, despite having raised disability-related reasons for needing more time, he was simply heading toward dismissal. The Tribunal held that the letter could and should have made clear what would happen at the meeting and that reasonable adjustments would be discussed. Because it did not, sending it in those terms was not proportionate.

The practical takeaway

The judgment is not authority for the proposition that employers must always grant more time whenever disability is mentioned.

It is, however, a good illustration for something more practical: once a disability-related explanation emerges, employers must ensure that their process, correspondence and decision-making visibly reflect that adjustments are still under consideration.

A generic capability or probation template may be administratively convenient, but if it communicates a harder line than the actual intended process, it can undermine justification and create liability.

Final point

There is also a useful litigation point that this case reminds parties of. The Employment Tribunal decided it was unnecessary to determine the reasonable adjustments claim separately because the same facts were better analysed under section 15.

For employers, employees and advisers, that is a reminder that proportionality under discrimination arising from disability may be the sharpest issue in cases where performance management and disability intersect.

Further Reading

Liability Judgment

Remedy Judgment

Disability Discrimination Article

Luca Liberti

About the Author:

Luca Liberti

Luca Liberti is the Director and Co-Founder of Morris Liberti. Qualifying as a solicitor in 2018, following his LLB Law Degree from the University of Essex and Legal Practice Course at BPP Law School, Cambridge. Outside of work, Luca serves as a school governor, supports Ipswich Town, and enjoys cycling and squash.

View All Posts by Luca Liberti
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.