What to Do If Your Legal Expenses Insurer Refuses Your Employment Claim
Legal expenses insurance can cover some or all of the cost of bringing an Employment Tribunal claim. It is commonly included with home insurance, certain bank accounts and professional or trade-union memberships.
However, having legal expenses cover does not mean that every proposed claim will be funded. Most policies require the claim to have “reasonable prospects of success” and to be proportionate to pursue.
If your insurer or its panel solicitor has assessed your claim below 51%, the insurer may refuse funding. That can be challenged in appropriate cases, but the correct approach is more involved than simply telling the insurer that you disagree.
This article is for information only and is not legal advice
What does 51% prospects of success mean?
The Financial Ombudsman Service interprets reasonable prospects of success as a 51% or greater chance of winning.
This is not necessarily an assessment of whether something unfair happened. The lawyer must consider whether the legal claims can be established using admissible evidence and whether they are more likely than not to succeed after taking account of the employer’s likely defence.
Different claims arising from the same employment dispute may have different prospects. For example, a lawyer could conclude that an unfair dismissal claim exceeds 51%, while a discrimination or whistleblowing claim does not.
The policy may also require the likely costs to be proportionate to the value of the claim. A case can therefore have reasonable prospects but still be declined if the anticipated cost is substantially greater than the realistic recovery.
Is the insurer entitled to rely on its panel solicitor?
Usually, yes, provided the advice is sufficiently reliable.
The Financial Ombudsman says an insurer should obtain advice from a suitably qualified legal professional. If the advice is clear, properly reasoned and not obviously wrong, the insurer is generally entitled to rely upon it.
The assessment might sometimes be prepared by a paralegal. That is not automatically improper if the work is undertaken under the supervision of a suitably qualified lawyer with relevant expertise.
The important questions are:
- Was all relevant evidence considered?
- Were the facts understood correctly?
- Were the correct legal tests applied?
- Were limitation issues addressed?
- Was the employer’s likely defence considered?
- Does the opinion explain how its conclusion was reached?
A short or disappointing assessment is not necessarily wrong. Equally, a long assessment is not necessarily sound.
Does a refusal mean that the employment claim cannot succeed?
No.
The insurer’s decision concerns whether the policy will fund the claim. It is not a judgment from the Employment Tribunal and does not prevent you from continuing privately, representing yourself or exploring another funding arrangement.
However, it is important to be realistic. An insurer’s refusal should not be dismissed simply because you strongly believe you were treated unfairly.
The Legal Ombudsman has also explained that a subsequent settlement does not, by itself, prove that the original assessment was wrong. Employers settle claims for many reasons, including the cost and disruption of defending them.
Can you obtain an independent merits assessment?
Yes. You can instruct another employment solicitor to provide an independent opinion.
The Financial Ombudsman says that when a policyholder disputes a legal opinion, the insurer will usually expect independent evidence from a qualified, comparable lawyer. If the solicitors disagree, the insurer will commonly need an opinion from a suitably qualified barrister with relevant legal knowledge.
There is an important qualification. You do not necessarily have an automatic right to make the insurer pay for the first independent assessment. That depends on the policy wording and anything agreed with the insurer.
Before instructing another solicitor, ask the insurer:
- Whether it will reconsider the decision on receipt of an independent opinion.
- What qualifications it requires from the reviewing lawyer.
- Whether it has a particular review or appeal procedure.
- Whether it will reimburse the assessment fee if the challenge succeeds.
- What will happen if the two solicitors disagree.
- Whether the dispute can be referred to a barrister or arbitration.
What should an independent assessment cover?
A useful assessment should engage directly with the reasons given for refusing cover. It should not merely state a different percentage.
The reviewing solicitor should ordinarily consider:
- The claims that are legally available.
- The legal test for each claim.
- The supporting and contradictory evidence.
- Any significant factual disputes.
- The employer’s pleaded or anticipated defence.
- Whether the claim was brought in time.
- The prospects of each material claim.
- The likely value of the claim.
- The estimated cost of pursuing it.
- Whether the case is proportionate to fund.
- The specific findings made by the original assessor.
Where the original opinion contains a factual error, the independent report should identify the error and explain whether correcting it materially changes the prospects.
Practical steps after a refusal
Obtain the complete decision
Ask for the insurer’s written decision and the underlying legal assessment. You need to understand whether the refusal concerns prospects, proportionality, policy coverage, late notification or another condition.
Check what documents were considered
Ask for confirmation of the documents provided to the assessor. A challenge may be justified if central evidence was omitted, but it is usually sensible to identify the missing evidence precisely.
Correct factual errors
Prepare a short list of material errors. Avoid responding to every sentence if it does not affect the conclusion.
For each error, explain:
- What the assessor said.
- Why it is incorrect.
- Which document proves the correct position.
- Why the correction affects the legal assessment.
Check the policy procedure
The policy may contain an appeal, review, arbitration or conflicting-opinion procedure. Follow that process and ask the insurer to confirm any applicable deadline.
Obtain a specialist opinion
Employment claims can involve specialist questions about discrimination, whistleblowing, dismissal, causation, limitation and compensation. The reviewing lawyer should have experience relevant to the claims being assessed.
Submit a focused challenge
Provide the independent opinion with a concise request that the insurer reconsider the claim. Identify any approaching ACAS or Tribunal deadlines and ask when the insurer expects to respond.
Use the complaints procedure if necessary
If the insurer maintains its refusal, you can make a formal complaint to the insurer. The insurer should issue a final response.
If you remain dissatisfied, or the insurer does not provide its final response within eight weeks, you may be able to complain to the Financial Ombudsman Service. The Ombudsman will not decide the underlying Employment Tribunal claim. It will consider whether the insurer acted fairly and reasonably when making its funding decision.
Complaints about the quality of service provided by a solicitor are generally dealt with through that firm’s complaints process and, where appropriate, the Legal Ombudsman.
Can you choose your own solicitor if funding is approved?
The right to choose a solicitor is separate from the merits assessment.
Regulation 6 of the Insurance Companies (Legal Expenses Insurance) Regulations 1990 protects the insured person’s freedom to choose a lawyer where a lawyer is required in an inquiry or proceedings, or where a genuine conflict of interest arises.
The Financial Ombudsman’s current approach is that an insurer can normally require the use of its panel before proceedings become necessary. Once proceedings need to be commenced, the policyholder should generally be allowed to nominate another solicitor.
The insurer can ask the chosen solicitor to agree appointment terms, reporting obligations and an hourly rate. It may restrict the amount it will pay, but the rate must not be so low that the freedom to choose a solicitor becomes meaningless.
Do not lose sight of the Employment Tribunal deadline
An insurer’s assessment, internal appeal or complaint does not suspend the time limit for commencing ACAS Early Conciliation or presenting an Employment Tribunal claim.
Do not wait for the insurance dispute to be resolved before protecting your position. If a deadline is approaching, obtain urgent advice about the steps required.
Insurers may also refuse to reimburse costs incurred before cover was accepted. Notify the insurer promptly and obtain written authority before incurring substantial legal costs wherever possible.
How Morris Liberti Legal can help
Morris Liberti Legal offers independent merits assessments for employees whose legal expenses insurer or panel solicitor has refused funding.
Our current fixed fees are:
- Up to 50 pages: £480 including VAT.
- Up to 100 pages: £570 including VAT.
We review the original assessment, the relevant evidence, the legal claims, prospects, value and proportionality. Where appropriate, our written report can be provided to the insurer in support of a request for reconsideration.
If funding is approved, we may also be able to represent you under the insurer’s terms, subject to capacity, conflicts checks and agreement over funding.
An independent assessment cannot guarantee that the insurer will change its decision. In some cases, our view may be the same as the panel solicitor’s. Our role is to provide a clear and independent assessment so that you can make an informed decision.
Contact Morris Liberti Legal for a no-obligation discussion about getting an independent merits assessment.
By telephone: 01449 280 280
By email: enquiries@morrisliberti.com
