Home > Articles > Your employer did not respond to your claim in the Employment Tribunal: what happens next?

Your employer did not respond to your claim in the Employment Tribunal: what happens next?

If you have started an Employment Tribunal claim and the employer does not respond (or does not respond in time), it can feel like you have “won”. In reality, it is usually the start of a different procedural track rather than an instant victory.

Tribunals generally try to decide cases fairly and on their merits. A late or missing response can put the employer at a serious disadvantage, but it does not always end the case there and then. Employers often still have routes to try to get back into the proceedings.

Below are the main outcomes you can expect.

Please note that this page is for general information only. It is not legal advice.

First, don’t assume it is over

A missing response is helpful for you, but it is rarely a guaranteed shortcut to compensation.

In many cases, the employer will be able to apply to take part late, or to challenge what happens next. Tribunals are alert to the fact that a procedural failure (like missing a deadline) can happen for reasons that are not connected to whether the claim has merit. This can seem very unfair to an employee who has taken the steps to prepare and file their claim within the tight time limits.

That said, the employer’s position is weaker than it would have been if they had responded properly and on time.

Before anything else: the Tribunal may check whether the claim was served correctly

If your employer has not responded to your claim, the Tribunal will often, but not always, take steps to satisfy itself that the claim was properly served on (sent to) the employer and that the employer had a fair chance to respond.

In practice, the Tribunal may:

  • check whether the employer’s contact details (registered office, trading address, or representative details) were correct,
  • consider whether there is any indication the ET1 was returned undelivered or otherwise not received, and
  • in some cases, issue directions or enquiries to you to clarify service before taking steps like default judgment.

This matters because if service was defective (or genuinely doubtful), the Tribunal is less likely to enter default judgment and more likely to ensure the claim is re-served or that the employer has a proper opportunity to engage before the case progresses.

It is important not to panic or be evasive with the Tribunal if they make enquiries and the claim may not have been served properly because of a minor error you made, the Tribunal understands that mistakes can happen.

Route 1: Default judgment (often followed by a Schedule of Loss)

Should the Tribunal be satisfied the claim was served properly, one typical route the Tribunal takes is to issue a default judgment because the employer has not entered a response.

What often happens next is:

  • The Tribunal may ask you for an up-to-date Schedule of Loss (your compensation breakdown) and sometimes evidence to support that, such as payslips, contracts of employment and applications for new work (to name a few things).
  • The Tribunal can then decide remedy based on the papers or list a short hearing if it needs evidence.

This can be a relatively efficient route, but the Tribunal still needs enough information to make a lawful award, particularly where injury to feelings, future loss, pension loss, or complex calculations are involved.

Practical point: even if liability is treated as established, you still need to prove your losses.

Route 2: The Judge wants to determine the merits

In some cases, the Judge may decide they still need to hear and determine the merits of the claim, even though the employer is currently barred from participating because they did not respond.

This is particularly common in discrimination cases, as these carry uncapped compensation and often have additional legal considerations, for example whether or not the employee is disabled.

Unless they have made a successful application for reconsideration, the employer will not be permitted to take part at that stage, but may be able to apply later to participate.

The practical effect is that you may still have to give evidence and prove the elements of your claim, but without the usual level of active resistance from the employer.

Route 3: The Tribunal lists a remedy hearing

Another common direction is for the Tribunal to list a remedy hearing to decide compensation (and any other remedies), even if liability has been dealt with by default.

The employer attends and can be heard on remedy

Even where the employer has not been able to participate on liability, the Tribunal may still allow them to attend the remedy hearing and make submissions on:

  • how compensation should be calculated,
  • whether parts of your loss are disputed (for example, if they believe you failed to be reasonable in your search for new work, future loss, pension), and
  • the appropriate injury to feelings band (in discrimination or detriment claims).

So, you may still face argument about the value of the claim, even if the employer cannot argue they did nothing wrong.

The employer does not attend and the Judge decides alone

If the employer does not attend the remedy hearing (or the Tribunal does not allow them to take part), the Judge can proceed in their absence and decide remedy based on:

  • your evidence,
  • your Schedule of Loss,
  • any documents already filed.

That does not mean the Tribunal will “rubber stamp” the number you ask for, as the Judge may still ask questions about your losses and need to be satisfied any losses claimed have been reasonably incurred. That said, it does often make the process more straightforward if your evidence is clear and properly supported.

At any time: the employer may try to get back in

A key point to understand is that a non-responding employer can still attempt to re-enter the case.

They may apply for reconsideration of decisions made in their absence (including default judgment and remedy decisions), usually arguing there is a good reason for the failure and that it is in the interests of justice for them to be allowed to participate.

Whether they succeed depends on the facts, including:

  • how late they are,
  • why they missed the deadline,
  • whether they acted promptly once they realised,
  • whether they have a real prospect of defending the claim, and
  • the prejudice to you if they are allowed back in.

In one case I dealt with, a judgment for compensation was issued by the Tribunal in September 2024, however upon application from the employer for reconsideration, they were allowed to participate fully a year later.

Should you oppose an employer’s application to be allowed back in? When it may be worth it, and when it may not

If the employer applies to be allowed to participate late (or applies for reconsideration of a default judgment or remedy decision), you have a choice: oppose it robustly, take a neutral position, or (occasionally) agree sensible directions. The right approach depends on what you gain or lose in practice.

When it is usually worth opposing

It is often worth opposing the application where one or more of the following apply:

  • They have no good reason for the failure to respond, or their explanation inconsistent, or unsupported by evidence.
  • They did not act promptly once they became aware of the issue (delay after discovery is often as damaging as the original default). “Promptly” can be within a few days, or even a week or so. It very much depends on the individual circumstances of the case.
  • You will suffer real prejudice if they are allowed back in, for example: you have already prepared the case (cost and time), key witnesses are now harder to secure, your health would be impacted by delay, and/or the hearing timetable will be disrupted, or a listed remedy hearing will be lost.
  • They do not appear to have a real defence on the face of it, and the application looks tactical (buying time, forcing you to incur cost, weakening settlement leverage).
  • You are close to a remedy decision and your Schedule of Loss and evidence are ready, so letting them back in mainly serves to reduce the value of the claim or drag things out.

Even if you oppose, focus your objection on the Tribunal’s usual themes: promptness, explanation, merits (whether there is a realistic defence), and prejudice to you.

When it may not be worth opposing

There are situations where opposing might not help you overall, or where a pragmatic position can be better:

  • There is a genuine service issue (wrong address, claim not received, technical problem). If service is genuinely doubtful, opposition may look unreasonable and the employer is more likely to get their application granted anyway.
  • The employer’s explanation is strong and evidenced, and they moved quickly (for example, sudden illness of the person dealing with the claim, credible IT failure, or a mistake corrected “promptly” (see above) once discovered).
  • The Tribunal is likely to grant it regardless, and fighting it just increases hostility and your workload without improving the outcome. For example, you may be required to attend a contested hearing to deal with the application.
  • Discrimination or complex factual cases where the Judge is likely to want a merits hearing in any event. If the Tribunal is going to investigate merits, your energy may be better spent strengthening evidence rather than a procedural fight.
  • You want to use it as leverage rather than fight it, for example:
    • you keep pressure on but signal you will not oppose if they agree a tight timetable and meaningful settlement discussions,
    • or you allow participation on remedy only, in exchange for concessions (issues list agreed, admissions, narrowed disputes).

What you should do now

  1. Keep pushing the case forward: comply with any Tribunal directions quickly and in full.
  2. Prepare a strong Schedule of Loss: with clear calculations, evidence for earnings, benefits, pension, job-search efforts, and any medical evidence where relevant.
  3. Treat remedy as a case you still need to prove: even with default judgment, compensation is not automatic.
  4. Do not assume that it’s over: you still need to be conscious that the employer may apply any time.

Frequently asked questions

If you need advice about the tribunal process, late defences, or any other employment law issue, Morris Liberti Legal will be pleased to help. Please contact us for a confidential, free initial discussion about your circumstances and the options available.

By telephone: 01449 280 280

By email: enquiries@morrisliberti.com

Luca Liberti

About the Author:

Luca Liberti

Luca Liberti is the Director and Co-Founder of Morris Liberti. Qualifying as a solicitor in 2018, following his LLB Law Degree from the University of Essex and Legal Practice Course at BPP Law School, Cambridge. Outside of work, Luca serves as a school governor, supports Ipswich Town, and enjoys cycling and squash.

View All Posts by Luca Liberti
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.