A settlement agreement is a legally binding contract that ends (or settles) employment issues in exchange for compensation and other terms. You don’t have to sign. You should get independent legal advice (the law requires it), and your employer will usually contribute to your legal fees.
Please note that this page is for general information only. It is not legal advice.
What is a Settlement Agreement?
A settlement agreement (previously a compromise agreement) is a contract where you agree not to bring (or to withdraw) employment tribunal claims in return for agreed payments and terms (confidentiality, reference, non-disparagement, etc.). It’s commonly used for redundancy situations, performance exits, grievances, unfair dismissal, discrimination, or where relations have simply broken down.
Key points:
- You must get independent legal advice on the terms and effect for it to be valid.
- Employers typically pay a contribution to your legal fees (often a fixed amount).
- You do not have to accept the first offer or an unrealistic deadline.
Do I have to sign?
No. You have a choice:
- Negotiate better terms (payment, reference, covenants, tax treatment).
- Decline and stay employed, or carry on with your employment tribunal claims (if the offer is premature or you want to continue).
- Bring or threaten claims (e.g., unfair dismissal, discrimination, whistleblowing) if appropriate and you haven’t done so already.
It isn’t always the case that employees want to reject the settlement, and some employees just ask for a solicitor to sign off the terms and help them understand what they are signing up to. Morris Liberti can help you work out your leverage (facts, risks, time limits) or weigh up the appropriateness of the offer so you can choose the route that suits you.
What should I get out of it?
There are usually three separate elements to a settlement agreement:
1. Financial sums
Termination payment (which can be tax free up to certain limits).
Notice: paid in lieu (PILON) or worked/
Bonus/commission: already earned or fairly in prospect.
Holiday pay and expenses owed.
Redundancy: statutory and any enhanced scheme.
2. Protections
Agreed reference.
Mutual non-disparagement (not just you).
Confidentiality with sensible carve-outs (immediate family, professional advisers, HMRC, regulators).
Waiver limited to employment claims up to the date of signing (not future injury or personal injury unrelated to the termination of your employment or its termination that you are not aware of).
No admission of liability wording that’s balanced, not one-sided.
3. Future-Proofing
Restrictive covenants: confirm, limit, or release where appropriate.
Garden leave/PILON interactions fixed cleanly.
IP, shares, options: what vests, and when.
Announcements: neutral wording, internal/external.
How much should I ask for?
There isn’t a universal calculator, but if you are not happy with the offer, Morris Liberti can help you look at:
- Legal risk (e.g., unfair dismissal, discrimination, whistleblowing).
- Process defects (procedure, investigation quality, selection pools).
- Loss of earnings (how long to find a similar role).
- Aggravating factors (health impact, dignity issues, reasonableness).
- Costs and time saved by settling now.
From there, we set an anchored target and a walk-away number, then negotiate.
Timelines, “deadlines” and pressure tactics
It is common for employers to put deadlines on the offer. But you control the pace more than you think. Employers often use “offer expires Friday” type language. That’s rarely a hard stop. If you’re being pushed, we’ll ask for a reasonable extension while we negotiate.
Tribunal time limits still matter. Even if you’re talking settlement, keep an eye on three months minus one day from the event for most claims, and consider ACAS Early Conciliation to protect your position if needed.
Protected conversations & “without prejudice”
- Protected conversations allow certain off-the-record discussions about ending employment.
- Without prejudice applies where there’s a genuine dispute.
Morris Liberti can sanity-check whether the label really applies, and whether anything said could still be used if needed.
Tax overview
- Notice pay/PILON is typically taxed as earnings.
- Part of a genuine termination (ex-gratia) payment may be paid tax-free up to a statutory threshold, with amounts above taxed.
- Deductions for employee NIC and income tax may apply depending on the component. We’ll co-ordinate wording so the tax intent is clear, while flagging that HMRC’s view prevails.
Our process
- Free initial advice (for employees). Send us the draft agreement and recent correspondence.
- Risk & value review. Your leverage, realistic range, priority terms.
- Negotiate (if appropriate). Payment, reference, restrictions, confidentiality, clean tax and announcements.
- Sign-off. We complete the certificate and deal with HR/payroll practicalities.
Frequently Asked Questions
If you need advice about a settlement agreement or any other employment law issue, Morris Liberti Legal will pleased to help. Please contact us for a confidential, free initial discussion about your circumstances and the options available.
By telephone: 01449 280 280
By email: enquiries@morrisliberti.com
