Learn what counts as unfair dismissal in the United Kingdom, who qualifies to claim, strict time limits, the “automatic” unfair reasons, and why imperfect procedures do not always decide the outcome. Includes the latest on the Employment Rights Bill (now Act) reforms.
Please note that this page is for general information only. It is not legal advice. To discuss the contents of this article or for legal advice on Unfair Dismissal please call us on 01449 280 280 or email enquiries@morrisliberti.com
Who can Bring an unfair dismissal claim?
To bring an ordinary unfair dismissal claim, you generally must:
- Have employee status (not a worker or self-employed contractor).
- Have two years’ continuous service with the same employer at the dismissal date (unless one of the “automatic” unfair reasons applies).
“Automatic” unfair reasons (below) protect employees regardless of length of service. In short, in some circumstances you can have unfair dismissal with under two years service.
Discrimination
If the dismissal is because of, or tainted by, unlawful discrimination under the Equality Act 2010 (for example related to sex, pregnancy and maternity, race, disability, age, religion or belief, sexual orientation, gender reassignment, or marriage and civil partnership), the Claimant can bring a discrimination claim without needing two years’ service.
In practice, a Claimant in this position may pursue a discrimination claim (day-one right) alongside any wrongful dismissal claim (for notice pay), even if they do not meet the two-year threshold for ordinary unfair dismissal.
Time limits: act fast
- The usual deadline is three months minus one day from the effective date of termination to start the tribunal process. Example:
- You were dismissed on 18 July 2025
- Your time limit expires on 17 October 2025
- Do not fall into the trap that your three months minus one day begins when the employer’s appeal process finishes.
- You must contact the ACAS to enter the matter into Early Conciliation before issuing a claim; doing so your time pauses (“stops the clock”) while conciliation runs, and time restarts on receipt of the certificate, usually giving you an extra month to send the claim to the Employment Tribunal. For example:
- You were dismissed on 18 July 2025
- You enter into ACAS Early Conciliation on 16 October 2025
- You get your ACAS Early Conciliation Certificate on 27 November 2025
- You then have until 27 December 2025 to bring the claim.
As we always say, do not leave it to the last day if you can help it. Prior preparation always beats last minute panic.
Fairness test in brief
A dismissal is unfair if the employer lacks a fair reason or acts unreasonably in treating that reason as sufficient for dismissal in all the circumstances (including procedure). Tribunals look at the employer’s decision-making at the time, not with hindsight
The potentially fair reasons an employer can have for dismissing an employee are as follows:
- Capability (either through performance, qualifications or ill-health)
- Conduct
- Redundancy
- If keeping an employee in that specific job would break the law, for either the employer or for the employee, for example, a bus driver losing his licence.
- Some other substantial reason
To act reasonably, the employer must genuinely and reasonably believe, following a reasonable investigation, that capability or conduct is unsatisfactory and must follow a fair procedure.
They should also consider lesser sanctions, reasonable adjustments and redeployment, including suitable alternative roles (and, for redundancy, SOSR or statutory illegality, consult and explore alternatives to dismissal).
Two important realities
- Not all flawed procedures = unfair dismissal
Even if a process error is found, the tribunal assesses overall reasonableness. Where a procedural flaw would not have changed the outcome, compensation can be reduced (often called a “Polkey” reduction). - Not all perfect procedures = fair dismissal
A polished process does not rescue a dismissal if the underlying reason is not sound or the decision falls outside the range of reasonable responses.
These principles flow from long-standing tribunal case law and are applied in current guidance.
“Automatic” unfair dismissal reasons (no service requirement)
Dismissal for any of the following is automatically unfair (non-exhaustive):
- Pregnancy, childbirth, maternity, paternity, adoption or shared parental leave.
- Making a protected disclosure (whistleblowing).
- Health and safety activities or raising safety concerns.
- Trade union membership, activities or recognition.
- Asserting a statutory right (for example, working time, national minimum wage).
These protections apply from day one; they sit alongside parallel protections under discrimination law.
Remedies at a glance
If a claim succeeds, tribunals can order reinstatement or re-engagement, and usually award basic and compensatory awards, subject to statutory limits and reductions for things like contributory conduct or the likelihood the dismissal would have occurred even with a fair process.
The average Unfair Dismissal UK payout for 2023/2024 was £13,749. With the largest award being £179,124.
What is changing? The Employment Rights Act 2025 at a glance
The Government’s Employment Rights Bill aims to deliver the “biggest upgrade to workers’ rights in a generation.” Headline proposals relevant to unfair dismissal and dismissal practice include:
Protection from unfair dismissal
Instead of removing the qualifying period entirely, the Act reduces the qualifying period from 2 years to 6 months (with existing day-one protections remaining for discrimination and “automatically unfair” reasons). Current published roadmaps/briefings indicate this change is expected to commence in 2027.
Longer tribunal time limits
The Bill proposes increasing the standard three-month limit for most employment claims to six months, though timings and staging depend on commencement regulations.
Curbing “fire and rehire” and regulating zero-hours arrangements.
Measures include stricter limits on contractual variation and protections for irregular-hours workers.
Implementation is being staged over 2025–2027. Always check commencement dates before advising on a live case. Practitioner briefings and official summaries continue to be updated as the Bill progresses.
Practical tips
- Do the basics well: Tell the Tribunal why you do not believe there was a fair reason, or the reason the employer relied was not genuine or how they got it wrong; explain what procedural errors your employer made, for example (but not limited), they did not meet with you, did not consider all relevant evidence, did not offer you the opportunity to bring a companion, they did not consider mitigation evidence, lesser sanctions or alternative roles.
- Mind the deadlines: diarise the three-months-minus-one-day rule. Start ACAS Early Conciliation promptly and do not leave it to the last minute.
- Do not assume service bars the claim: automatic unfair reasons and discrimination claims have no two-year requirement.
Frequently asked questions
If you need advice about dismissal, redundancy, a disciplinary or any other employment law issue, Morris Liberti Legal will be pleased to help. Please contact us for a confidential, free initial discussion about your circumstances and the options available.
By telephone: 01449 280 280
By email: enquiries@morrisliberti.com
