Most Employment Tribunal claims do not end with a final hearing and a written judgment. In practice, the majority resolve by agreement, often well before a judge hears any evidence.
Understanding when settlement makes sense, how it usually happens, and what to watch out for can help you make informed decisions about your case.
Please note that this page is for general information only. It is not legal advice. It is important to note that each case is unique, and you should seek legal advice where possible on the best approach to take in relation to settlement.
The reality: mANY claims settle
Employment Tribunal statistics show that around three-quarters of claims are recorded as settled or withdrawn before reaching a final hearing. Only a relatively small proportion proceeds all the way to judgment.
The latest ACAS Annual Report states that only about 5% of tribunal notifications are now actually heard by a judge, and after Employment Tribunal proceedings are issued, 79% of cases are positively conciliated.
That does not mean settlement is always the right answer. It does mean that settlement is the normal outcome in many cases, for reasons that apply to both employees and employers.
Why you may want to settle
1. Certainty of outcome
Employment Tribunal claims are inherently uncertain; the way employment law has developed through legislation and case law means that judges can have wide discretion in making decisions on whether or not your case or defence is successful and what may be awarded.
Even strong claims or defences carry risk. Judges will assess witness credibility, evidence, and reasonableness (which in itself carries a lot of subjectivity), and outcomes can turn on small factual differences or witness performances on the day of the hearing.
By settling, you exchange uncertainty for a known result. That can be particularly valuable where:
- Your finances or resources are under pressure
- You want to move on professionally
- The evidence is mixed rather than clear-cut (in your favour)
2. Time and emotional cost
Employment Tribunal claims often take many months, sometimes years, to reach a final hearing. During that time, you may need to:
- Prepare detailed statements
- Disclose large volumes of documents
- Attend preliminary hearings
- Relive difficult events
- Take time out from your new employer, or release employees and management from important day-to-day operations.
Even where the legal merits are strong, the personal cost or cost to the day-to-day running of your business can be significant.
Settlement brings matters to an end sooner.
3. Financial risk and reward in context
Tribunal awards vary widely and depend heavily on the facts.
For example, recent statistics show that in unfair dismissal cases:
- the median award is typically around £6,000 to £7,000
- the average award is higher, reflecting a small number of very high awards
- very large awards are statistically rare
Discrimination awards can be higher and are uncapped, but again most awards sit well below headline figures reported in the press.
4. Managing costs exposure
Employment Tribunals do not generally follow the “loser pays” rule, but costs orders are not impossible.
Statistics indicate that costs are awarded in a small minority of cases, usually where a party has acted unreasonably or pursued a claim or continued with a defence with little prospect of success.
5. Non-financial outcomes
Tribunals are limited in what they can order. Settlement allows you to agree outcomes a judge cannot impose, such as:
- an agreed reference
- confidentiality and non-disparagement
- agreed wording for internal or external announcements
- a clean break without admissions
For many employees, these terms matter as much as the money.
How settlement usually happens
Settlement is not a single process. It can take several forms, and discussions can be started, stopped, and restarted at any point during the process.
Without prejudice negotiations
Settlement discussions can also take place directly between the parties or their solicitors on a “without prejudice” basis.
This allows open negotiation without the content being shown to the Tribunal if talks fail.
These discussions can happen:
- before any claim is issued
- after a claim has been filed
- right up to, and sometimes during, the final hearing
You can engage in these negotiations at any time. Correspondence should be marked as “Without Prejudice” and should state that any offer is “subject to contract” as the parties agree on a financial settlement, but one other party could still insist on unreasonable terms, making settlement difficult or even impossible.
If any agreement is reached on a settlement figure and any non-financial terms an agreement can be made “legally binding” in one of two ways:
ACAS Early Conciliation
Before issuing most Tribunal claims, you must notify ACAS and enter Early Conciliation.
A conciliator acts as an independent intermediary and can help broker a deal. They do not give legal advice or take sides, but they can:
- communicate offers
- reality-test positions
- record binding agreements
If settlement is reached through ACAS, it is usually recorded in a COT3 agreement.
Settlement agreements
Some disputes resolve through a formal settlement agreement, particularly where employment is ending or has ended.
These agreements require independent legal advice for the employee and usually include:
- compensation
- waiver of claims
- confidentiality provisions
- reference wording
For more on settlement agreements, check out our Settlement Agreement Article.
What should you settle for?
This is difficult to answer as it depends on the type of case you are bringing, your losses and specific circumstances.
Every case is unique and to answer that question more accurately, tailored legal advice can certainly help.
Whilst settlements are usually not recorded publicly, you can get a useful benchmark on what the Tribunal may award from Tribunal statistics, including the highest and average awards for your type of claim. Of course these do not tell the full story, and it can be difficult to compare your situation with what happened in those claims.
Those Award statistics at a glance
The latest full dataset available is for the 2023/24 tax year, and in this article we focus only on a small number of the most common claim types, because tribunal awards vary significantly depending on the nature of the claim and the remedies the tribunal can award. These are:
- Unfair Dismissal:
- The largest award was: £179,124
- The average award was: £13,749
- The median award was: £6,746
- Race Discrimination:
- The largest award was: £431,786
- The average award was: £29,532
- The median award was: £10,253
- Sex Discrimination:
- The largest award was: £995,128
- The average award was: £53,403
- The median award was: £16,161
- Disability Discrimination:
- The largest award was: £964,465
- The average award was: £44,483
- The median award was: £17,218
Tribunal awards are often skewed by a small number of very high payouts; the median is usually the best figure to look at, as it shows the “typical” award and is not distorted by unusually high awards.
Another useful source is the Employment Tribunal decisions database, where you can filter and review cases that have been decided.
It is also worth noting that Tribunal awards are not always a reliable indicator. As explained in this article, there are many reasons why you may choose to settle for less than the maximum you could achieve at Tribunal.
When can you settle?
The short answer is almost at any point.
Before a claim is issued
Many cases settle:
- during internal procedures
- after a grievance or appeal
- during ACAS Early Conciliation
Early settlement can save time and stress, but you should still be mindful of limitation deadlines while discussions continue.
After a claim is issued
Settlement after issuing a claim is extremely common. Employers often reassess risk once they see the pleaded case and evidence.
Key points where settlement discussions often intensify include:
- after the response is filed
- following preliminary hearings
- after disclosure of documents
- once witness statements are exchanged
On the eve of, or during, the hearing
It is not unusual for cases to settle very late, sometimes even on the morning of the final hearing.
At that stage:
- costs and preparation are at their highest
- risk is clearer on both sides
- commercial pressure increases
Practical tips if you are considering settlement
Keep deadlines protected
Settlement talks do not stop Tribunal time limits. Always ensure:
- ACAS Early Conciliation is started in time
- Your claim is issued within the deadline
- You keep to deadlines imposed by the Tribunal, such as filing your defence or disclosure of evidence.
You can negotiate and litigate at the same time.
Know your objectives
Before negotiating, be clear on:
- Your realistic valuation range
- Your non-negotiables, such as a reference
- What outcome would allow you to move on
Avoid false assumptions
Settlement does not mean your claim or defence is weak.
Employers often settle strong claims to control risk, cost, and reputational exposure.
Equally, settlement does not mean your claim or defence is strong. The same reasons why employer may settle stronger claims can apply to weaker claims too.
Get advice where possible
Understanding leverage, valuation, and timing can materially affect outcomes.
Even limited advice can help you avoid under- or over-estimating your position.
Frequently asked questions
If you would like advice on the likely value of your employment claim, Morris Liberti Legal can help. We offer a free initial discussion to talk through your circumstances, the potential value of your case, and the options available to you. Please contact us for a confidential, free initial discussion about your circumstances and the options available.
By telephone: 01449 280 280
By email: enquiries@morrisliberti.com
